Past performance is not a forecast
A fund with the highest historical return is not automatically suitable for you. Compare funds with similar mandates, currency and risk exposure, and use matching dates and consistent treatment of fees.
| Research field | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Fund / share class | A similar name can hide different costs or mandates. |
| 1, 3, 5 and 10-year returns | Use a matching end date; distinguish cumulative from annualised returns. |
| Risk and asset mix | Higher returns may come with larger falls in value. |
| Charges | Establish which charges are already reflected in returns. |
| Source date | Read the current provider factsheet and key information. |
Bring the source documents into your review
This site does not publish an unsourced live performance league table. Use current provider factsheets for historical figures and request help interpreting them alongside your pension contract.
How we handle research and comparisons →
Rules depend on your circumstances.
Would you like help reviewing a fund?
Get useful information before you decide whether to request a personal review.
Request a fund review ↗Begin with the investment objective
A growth fund, bond fund, cash fund and retirement-date strategy are designed for different jobs. Comparing their returns without considering risk and asset mix can reward the wrong behaviour. First identify the fund objective, benchmark, currency exposure and expected holding period.
Use matching periods and consistent figures
Compare the same start and end dates and establish whether performance is cumulative or annualised. Confirm whether published returns are before or after fund-management charges. A five-year annualised number is not five times a one-year return because investment returns compound.
Risk measures that add context
- Volatility: how widely returns have moved around their average.
- Maximum drawdown: the largest peak-to-trough decline in the measured period.
- Asset concentration: dependence on a small number of markets, sectors or securities.
- Currency exposure: gains or losses created by exchange-rate movements.
- Sequence risk: the effect of losses close to retirement while withdrawals or de-risking occur.
Default and lifestyle strategies
Many workplace pensions use a default strategy when the member makes no fund choice. It may change assets automatically as the recorded retirement date approaches. Check the retirement outcome it targets. A strategy aligned with annuity purchase may not match a plan to remain invested through an ARF.
Information members can request
Where members bear investment risk, occupational schemes provide information about available options, the default strategy, investment managers, portfolio and risk, charges and past performance. Current rules refer to at least five years of past performance, or the life of a newer scheme. The statement of investment policy principles explains how trustees set and manage the scheme investment strategy.
A practical fund-review process
- Write down the retirement objective and time horizon.
- Identify current assets, risk and diversification.
- Compare a relevant benchmark and genuinely comparable funds.
- Review performance net of known charges.
- Check whether recent returns came from concentrated risk.
- Confirm the switching process, cost and time out of market.
- Record the reason for any change before acting.
Should I switch after a fund falls?
A fall alone does not show that switching is appropriate. Check the cause, objective, risk capacity and effect of selling after the decline.
Does the best five-year fund stay best?
No. Rankings change, and strong historical returns can reflect higher risk or a favourable market cycle.